Ryan Serhant has sold New York real estate for years, and he now says the whole system is stacked against people who want to move. The founder of SERHANT. told Fox News Digital at his SoHo headquarters that mortgage rates and prices are “only a small piece” of what he calls “not even a housing market, but a housing obstacle course.” He said the game has “somewhat been rigged by those who created the obstacle course in the first place,” and that it punishes mobility in favor of stability.
The rate backdrop
The rate picture is grim enough. As of Thursday, the Mortgage Research Center put the average 30-year fixed refinance at 7.11%, up from 7.07% a week earlier. The 15-year fixed refinance averaged 6.34%. The Federal Reserve raised the federal funds target range last week from 3.5%-3.75% to 3.75%-4%. It was a 25-basis-point move and the first hike since July 2023, coming after the Fed held rates at its first five meetings this year. A new Redfin report showed U.S. home prices up 3.7% year over year in August, the fastest annual pace in a year.
Costs hiding behind the headline
Serhant’s point is about everything that sits on top. Rising property taxes, insurance premiums and local regulatory friction, he argued, increasingly decide where families can afford to settle. Some owners are tempted by states with no income tax, such as Florida and Texas, but he warned that carrying costs can wipe out the saving. In Florida, he said, property tax is “almost 2%” of what you pay, and then come sales taxes and the cost of homeowners insurance in a coastal city. “God forbid there’s a hurricane, let alone a tornado, let alone an earthquake, let alone a forest fire,” he said.
People, he added, move with their wallets and with their hearts.
The pied-à-terre problem
He also took aim at New York City’s new surcharge on non-primary residences, the pied-à-terre tax. It has not pushed people out of the city, he said. It has frozen the people in the middle, for whom the payment really does hit the monthly budget. His example was a couple with a one- or two-bedroom near a daughter who lives in New York, who might now skip their yearly trips to Broadway. Rather than forcing wealthy sellers to cut prices, he argued, such assessments can freeze middle-tier buyers in place and feed wider gridlock.
Governments, he said, need to think 10 or 20 years ahead, even if their constituents are thinking about Saturday and tomorrow’s commute. He named New York, Seattle and much of California as places taking a short-term view of growth, and called that frustrating.
What really moves buyers, Serhant said, is job growth, access to education and security. He pointed to Charlotte, North Carolina, one of the first markets his firm entered three years ago, as the fastest-growing city of the past year. The Carolinas, he said, are overlooked because “they don’t get the clicks.” Because capital and work are now geographically flexible, he argued, states and cities that add administrative friction risk losing investment to rivals. His company, he said, is doing its small part to reduce that friction in property, “the largest asset class on earth.”





